One-sided perceived pitch issues

  • Right after the latest update (thank you! the recording syncing was definitely crazy there for a bit!), I had a violin student the other day sounding a semitone flat in a lesson. We are both on the latest FarPlay version, and using Macs, wired headphones, ethernet, and external mics.

    We checked her violin against mine, her three tuners, and my tuner. I saw clearly that she was tuned according to her tuners and she said she sounded in tune to my violin and my tuning tone (and I do trust her ear), however she continued sounding a half step flat to me throughout the lesson. Reviewing the lesson recording, she was in fact perfectly in tune. The same issue has not happened with any other students, before or after this update.

    Google suggested there was a mismatch between a 48kHz and 44.1kHz sample rate and how we could go into “Audio MIDI setup” and manually make sure headphones and mics are all set to 48kHz. All ours were, so I’m not sure that was really it, but it was long after the fact so maybe it was something that had already sorted itself out.

    Anyhow, we’ll see if it fixes itself or double checking that manual selection fixes it the next time I see her, but I’m wondering if you have any ideas/thoughts? Her headphones were the correct selection but had just said “default” if that’s helpful? I’m not sure how FarPlay talks to these sound controls, or if it might be an entirely different phenomenon, but maybe there’s a discrepancy in how this sample rate is being chosen somewhere? It was definitely a bit of a “twilight zone” experience for me!

    Thanks!
    Laurel

  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.